Developers obtain a replacement permit for the Raritan Bay underwater methane pipeline expansion.
The 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals invalidated a key permit for the New Jersey-Long Island gas project. Obtaining a new permit resolves this.
Across 6 frontier models answering independently, the panel thinks this is unlikely: the median is 22%.
They do not agree: GPT puts it at 57% and Gemini at 22%, 35 points apart. A spread that wide usually means the question turns on something none of them can see yet.
Nothing is settled until 27 Sept 2027, when the outcome is checked against sources and every number above gets a permanent score.
What each one said
-
GPTOpenAI
The key determinant is whether the responsible federal agency can cure the Third Circuit’s identified defect within a year.
- Developers must submit a revised application and the permitting agency must issue a replacement by September 27, 2027.
- Vacatur usually permits a remand-and-reissue cycle, but new environmental review or state-coastal objections can extend it beyond 12 months.
- Odds would rise sharply if the agency sets a remand schedule promptly; a broader project redesign or fresh litigation would cut them.
57% -
QwenAlibaba
FERC re-permitting for a struck pipeline is fast, but NJDEP and Army Corps reviews for underwater methane work are the real bottleneck.
- The 3rd Circuit struck a federal permit (likely FERC or Clean Water Act §401); FERC can reissue within 6–12 months, but NJDEP coastal zone consistency and Army Corps…
- The project (NJ–Long Island pipeline) faces strong opposition from NJ environmental groups and the Murphy administration, which has historically delayed or denied…
- If the court's invalidation was narrow (procedural rather than substantive), re-permitting could clear by mid-2027; a substantive ruling on environmental impact would…
31% -
GeminiGoogle
New Jersey DEP opposition and NY/NJ climate mandates make re-permitting the NESE pipeline extension legally and politically toxic.
- Williams must restart state water quality reviews where NJ DEP and NY DEC have already rejected permits repeatedly.
- The 12-month window is too narrow for an environmental impact revision, public comment periods, and subsequent approvals.
- A major shift toward federal preemption under the Natural Gas Act or a Trump administration FERC overhaul would change odds.
22% -
ClaudeAnthropic
Turns on whether developers restart a multi-agency federal/state permitting process fast enough to clear it by Sept 2027.
- Post-vacatur permitting typically takes 2-4 years given NEPA review, Army Corps, and state coastal consistency reviews.
- Court invalidation often signals deeper legal/environmental flaws that slow remediation beyond a one-year window.
- Political and litigation risk from environmental groups likely triggers further delays or a renewed court challenge.
22% -
GrokxAI
NJDEP (or successor agency) must reissue a 401/water-quality cert after the 3rd Circuit vacatur.
- Williams must file a complete new application within weeks of today; NJDEP then has 6–12 months of review plus comment, so a 2027-09-27 decision is already tight.
- Northeast gas-pipeline 401 recertifications after court losses succeed <25 % inside one year (Constitution, PennEast precedents); this sits below that given NY/NJ…
- A new NJ governor elected Nov 2025 could reverse course, but no public signal of that has appeared by late 2026.
22% -
DeepSeekDeepSeek
Turns on whether NJ DEP reissues a water-quality permit the 3rd Circuit vacated, and whether the pipeline's economics still justify it.
- The 3rd Circuit vacated the NJ DEP water quality certificate; a replacement must come from NJ DEP under Clean Water Act §401, not the feds.
- NJ DEP review plus any new hearing realistically takes 12-24 months, leaving little margin before the September 2027 deadline.
- Precedent is poor: the project's backers have already signaled cost and demand doubts, and a reissued permit would likely draw fresh litigation.
22%
6 of 6 models answered · 35 points between the highest and lowest. None was shown the market price.
Question sourced from a news sweep on 27 Sept 2026. Forecast by google/gemini-3.8-flash, anthropic/claude-sonnet-5, openai/gpt-5.6-terra, x-ai/grok-4.6, deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash, qwen/qwen3.8-max-0902 via OpenRouter.